I’ve worked on a wide — you could say wild — variety of cases in my 30+ year legal career, but occasionally a field or topic emerges that’s outside my experience. Continuing Legal Ed — or CLE, said Cee Ell Ee in some states, Klee in others — courses are some of the best “new topic” alerts.
One showed up in my mailbox earlier this week that I think has, sadly, enormous story potential: a seven-hour class sponsored by the CLE Institute of the State Bar of Montana on Litigating Parental Alienation Cases.” Micro version: One parent claims the other has deliberately interfered with his or her relationship with their child, and asks a court to intervene.
From the brochure: “This workshop will help attorneys recognize PA. Participants will learn to identify specific behaviors of the favored, or alienating, parent, and those of the rejected parent and the affected child that are commonly observed in these cases. Presenters will cover what PA is and provide suggestions about case management, litigation strategy, and options for families where PA is at issue.”
Speakers include a psychologist, licensed professional counselors, and an attorney who has worked extensively as a guardian ad litem (meaning she’s been appointed to advocate for the children, for the limited purposes of the litigation), parenting evaluator, and family law mediator.
Some of the topics on the schedule:
“Essence of Parenting—Attachment Theory and Failures of Compassion”
“Introduction to Parental Alienation”
“Primary Manifestations of PA — Levels of PA”
“Specific PA Behaviors—Introduction to Bayes’ Theorem”
“DSM-5” (a discussion of applicable topics from the Diagnostic & Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 5th edition)
Others: gathering evidence, examining experts, controversies, a discussion of case law, the role of guardians ad litem, parenting evaluations and parenting coordinators, family reunification options, and alternative placement options for severely alienated children.
It’s easy to roll our eyes or shake our heads at some of the terminology, which can border on psycho babble. Or to shake our heads over the terrible things people do to children—although frankly, I’m not so sure that the world is any worse than it always was; we just have new terms and ways of understanding human problems. And that’s the key, I think, to using this kind of information in your stories: use it to uncover the heart of the conflict between your characters, to understand how they respond and react, how they externalize or demonstrate their emotions. How does a bystander—a grandparent, a teacher, a family friend, a parent’s new partner, an older sibling—respond? And yes, how do law enforcement and judicial systems become involved? Because, ultimately, story is part of how we understand and cope with the world around us.
(Painting: Plum Lovely, acrylic on canvas, by my friend Christine Vandeberg)
Do you know anything about Grandparent Alienation? Like, is there such a thing (in the legal system)? And what, if any, recourse is open to grandparents?
Cherie, I haven’t heard of such a claim, but that doesn’t mean it doesn’t exist. Grandparents don’t have the same legal rights as parents have. Of course, if the grandparent has legal custody, then the same sort of custodial interference and alienation principles apply as to claims by parents. If they don’t, then things get tricky; state law on grandparent visitation rights varies greatly, and could affect the ability to bring a claim. If you’re looking for story potential, you might talk with a family law professor at a law school in your story state. If you’re dealing with a real-life situation, consult an experienced family lawyer.
Thanks! The situation has story potential, but probably too sad for my style. Maybe for one of those made-for-tv, tear-jerker movies.
I have seen it happen as I’m sure you have. How sad.
Fascinating. I think this happens with a lot of custodial kidnapping cases, too.
Yes, I think they’re closely tied, with bad behavior knowing no gender or social boundaries.
Your advice is greatly appreciated, even if I won’t use that particular idea in any of my stories. It helps me build a knowledge base that does add to my stories. As for the grand parent alienation, I thought I read somewhere, at sometime, that there was case that helped grandparents assert their rights. Am I wrong?
Cheri, you’re welcome. About grandparent alienation, you may well be right — family law is not my expertise. I can say that grandparents’ legal rights vary greatly by state, and depending on the facts of the case, so any author writing about them should research the law in the story state.